Civil3D-mcp

★ 53

portfolio-mcp

★ 12

Civil3D-mcp vs portfolio-mcp

Q: Which is better, Civil3D-mcp or portfolio-mcp?

By GitHub stars, Civil3D-mcp has more community adoption, but the best choice depends on your specific use case.

Civil3D-mcp: Civil3D-MCP connects AI assistants like Claude and Cursor to live Autodesk Civil 3D drawings via the Model Context Protocol. It enables real-time interaction, allowing AI to read drawing data, perform calculations, and make changes to civil engineering designs through a Node.js server and a native Civil 3D plugin.; portfolio-mcp: portfolio-mcp is a Model Context Protocol (MCP) server that allows users to interact with their XP Investimentos portfolio via Claude Desktop. It processes official PDF/CSV exports from XP, stores the normalized data in a local SQLite database, and answers portfolio-related questions without sending sensitive information externally. It provides analytical tools for asset allocation, returns calculation, and market data screening.

TL;DR

Civil3D-mcpWorkflow Automation · ★ 53

Performing comprehensive QC checks on corridors and generating reports.

Read Civil3D-mcp full review →

portfolio-mcpRAG / Knowledge Base · ★ 12

Compare current allocation against a target portfolio and suggest rebalancing actions.

Read portfolio-mcp full review →

Side-by-Side Comparison

Field

Civil3D-mcp

portfolio-mcp

Features

Civil3D-mcp

01Connect AI assistants to live Civil 3D drawings for real-time interaction.

02Access local Autodesk help and tutorial videos directly within the chat interface.

03Automate native Civil 3D workflows for tasks like grading, hydrology, and plan production.

04Offers a compact set of 34 public tools covering all major Civil 3D domains with robust internal capabilities.

portfolio-mcp

01Local-first data storage in SQLite with zero outbound HTTP calls for core tools.

02No credentials or web scraping required; users import PDF/CSV exports directly.

03Read-only by design, ensuring no orders can be placed or modifications made at XP.

04Stdio transport for secure communication with Claude Desktop, no open ports.

05Idempotent import of PDF/CSV files to prevent data duplication.

Use Cases

Civil3D-mcp

↳Performing comprehensive QC checks on corridors and generating reports.

↳Automating tasks like watershed delineation, runoff estimation, and storm drain network sizing.

↳Publishing Plan Production sheet sets to PDF for easy sharing and archiving.

↳Calculating cut/fill volumes between different surface models for earthwork analysis.

portfolio-mcp

↳Compare current allocation against a target portfolio and suggest rebalancing actions.

↳Query specific assets, such as CDBs maturing in a given year.

↳List portfolio positions grouped by asset class with detailed values.

↳Get a comprehensive portfolio summary including P&L, FGC coverage, and maturity overview.

↳Calculate time-weighted return (TWR) and money-weighted return (MWR) for the portfolio.

FAQ

What is the difference between Civil3D-mcp and portfolio-mcp?

Both Civil3D-mcp and portfolio-mcp are in the Workflow Automation category. Civil3D-mcp has 53 stars, while portfolio-mcp has 12 stars.

Which is better, Civil3D-mcp or portfolio-mcp?

The best choice depends on your use case. Choose Civil3D-mcp if Performing comprehensive QC checks on corridors and generating reports., and portfolio-mcp if Compare current allocation against a target portfolio and suggest rebalancing actions..

Is Civil3D-mcp free or open source?

Yes, Civil3D-mcp is open source on GitHub (MIT).

Is portfolio-mcp free or open source?

Yes, portfolio-mcp is open source on GitHub (MIT).

Cloud Infrastructure

Deploy on DigitalOcean

Host your MCP servers, Docker containers, and AI agents with $200 free credit over 60 days.

Claim $200 Free Credit

→

Alternatives to Civil3D-mcp →Alternatives to portfolio-mcp →Civil3D-mcp details →portfolio-mcp details →

TL;DR

Side-by-Side Comparison

Features

Use Cases

FAQ

Deploy on DigitalOcean

Related