AgentIndex icon
AgentIndex
StructSmith logo
StructSmith
★ 26
vs
sap-adt-mcp logo
sap-adt-mcp
★ 20

StructSmith vs sap-adt-mcp

StructSmith: StructSmith is a local-first, open-source tool for modeling software architecture, offering a modern React Flow editor and built-in MCP for AI client integration. It allows users to model, document, and share software architecture with AI assistants, providing a self-hosted alternative to Structurizr.; sap-adt-mcp: sap-adt-mcp is an MCP server that enables AI assistants like Claude to interact directly with SAP systems via the ABAP Development Tools (ADT) API. It offers 27 high-level tools for common SAP development tasks, from source code management and quality checks to cross-system comparisons and transport operations.

01

TL;DR

StructSmith logo
StructSmithDev Tooling · ★ 26

Designing and documenting software architecture, including using the C4 model.

Read StructSmith full review →
sap-adt-mcp logo
sap-adt-mcpDev Tooling · ★ 20

Automating repetitive SAP ABAP development tasks like source code analysis and quality checks.

Read sap-adt-mcp full review →
02

Side-by-Side Comparison

Field
StructSmith logoStructSmith
sap-adt-mcp logosap-adt-mcp
Category
Dev Tooling
Dev Tooling
Stars
★ 26
★ 20
License
MIT
MIT
Install Command
docker run -d --name structsmith -p 127.0.0.1:8090:8080 -v structsmith-data:/data --restart unless-stopped ghcr.io/dziksu/structsmith:latest
npm install -g sap-adt-mcp
Updated
1d ago
2w ago
Open Source
Yes
Yes
Website
↗ Visit
↗ Visit
GitHub
↗ GitHub
↗ GitHub
Tags
Software Architecture, C4 Model, Architecture Diagramming
SAP, ADT, ABAP
03

Features

StructSmith logoStructSmith
01Local-first, open-source, MIT licensed with no accounts or telemetry, working fully offline.
02Modern React Flow editor for visualizing and laying out semantic architecture models.
03Built-in Model Context Protocol (MCP) for seamless integration with various AI clients.
04Support for C4 model elements, relationships, views, and semantic nested boundaries.
05Import existing Mermaid diagrams and export to JSON, Mermaid, PNG, or SVG formats.
sap-adt-mcp logosap-adt-mcp
01Provides 27 high-level tools for common SAP ADT operations.
02Supports multi-system awareness for configuration and cross-system comparisons.
03Offers granular read-only mode for secure operations on SAP systems.
04Includes robust features like CSRF token negotiation, per-request timeouts, and self-signed certificate handling.
05Parses ADT's XML exceptions into structured error messages for agents.
04

Use Cases

StructSmith logoStructSmith
↳Designing and documenting software architecture, including using the C4 model.
↳Facilitating architecture workshops and designing system integrations.
↳Collaborating on architecture work with AI assistants.
↳Creating presales and solution architecture diagrams.
↳Documenting existing systems and their components.
sap-adt-mcp logosap-adt-mcp
↳Automating repetitive SAP ABAP development tasks like source code analysis and quality checks.
↳Performing cross-system comparisons and transport object management.
↳Assisting with SAP Clean Core implementation, including code grading, review, and refactoring.
↳Triaging ST22 short dumps and reverse-documenting legacy ABAP code.
↳Integrating AI agents (like Claude) directly with live SAP development and quality assurance systems.
FAQ

FAQ

What is the difference between StructSmith and sap-adt-mcp?
Both StructSmith and sap-adt-mcp are in the Dev Tooling category. StructSmith has 26 stars, while sap-adt-mcp has 20 stars.
Which is better, StructSmith or sap-adt-mcp?
The best choice depends on your use case. Choose StructSmith if Designing and documenting software architecture, including using the C4 model., and sap-adt-mcp if Automating repetitive SAP ABAP development tasks like source code analysis and quality checks..
Is StructSmith free or open source?
Yes, StructSmith is open source on GitHub (MIT).
Is sap-adt-mcp free or open source?
Yes, sap-adt-mcp is open source on GitHub (MIT).
Cloud Infrastructure
Ad

Deploy on DigitalOcean

Host your MCP servers, Docker containers, and AI agents with $200 free credit over 60 days.

Claim $200 Free Credit
→

Related

Alternatives to StructSmith →Alternatives to sap-adt-mcp →StructSmith details →sap-adt-mcp details →